Pie

If you love pizza then you MUST stop here. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, the pizza was out of this world, and the staff was incredible. They were so accommodating to us. I haven’t had service this good in a long time. It was much appreciated. The pizza was made from fresh ingredients and the topping combinations were so good. 10 out of 10. The next time I come to Bethany I am definitely coming back.

Pizza was great! Pie was okay. Too cold and a little soggy. Wait staff amazing & on top of things.

Very impressed with this yummy location.

Hubs is a pizza fanatic and loves to try it everywhere we go so, this was our spot after looking at pics and reviews.

I love their flatbread-looking pizzas with thin crust. These are more like a rectangle than a traditional circle shape. We each had a salad which was fresh and delicious and a large portion and split a pizza with cheese and sausage. The salads were really good and a super fair price for the size!

Pizza was SO good. Fresh-made to order, hot and perfectly cooked. Crust was just crunchy enough and not overdone and no part of the dough was uncooked. Excellent. They know how to make a good pizza.

We didn't get any pie for dessert but they had several flavors and all looked wonderful.

Service was great and it’s a charming building from both inside and outside. Clean restroom and very clean tables. Plenty of nearby parking.